Labyrinths of Belief: Notes on Joss Whedon's Dollhouse Part II: Briar Rose

Labyrinths of Belief: Notes on Joss Whedon's Dollhouse Part II: Briar Rose

This is the summary



This is the rest of the post

Dollhouse

Dollhouse is a science-fiction series, created by Joss Whedon of Buffy and Firefly fame, which revolves around the exploits of an operatives of a mysterious organization known as the Dollhouse, the eponymous umbrella name for an organization that actually runs a myriad of dollhouses all over the world. These operatives, or "Actives" or "Dolls" as they are interchangeably called by the organization, are unique in that their personalities and memory of their existence in the outside world have been wiped clean so that they they may be imprinted with any number of new personalities for different assignments (referred to as engagements).

The new persona is an amalgam of several real people, which necessarily incorporates both strengths and flaws from the template personalities. The Actives are then hired out for engagements that can range anywhere from crimes to fantasies, to the occasional good deed. On engagements, Actives are monitored internally (and remotely) by Handlers. In between engagements they are mind-wiped into a child-like state and live in a futuristic dormitory, a hidden facility named "The Dollhouse." The Dollhouse is located somewhere in Los Angeles and is a subsidiary of a mysterious research company known as the Rossum Corporation. Dollhouse isn't exactly what one would call a "good" show. Don't get me wrong, it has its moments and had an especially strong second half of the season. However, it often found itself struggling with what type of show it wished to be (episodic doll-of-the-week, sci-fi police procedural, philosophically-driven concept show about human nature) and what audience it wished to draw.


The protagonist of the show is the operative Echo (all operatives are named after characters from the NATO phonetic alphabet), a young woman whose actual name was Caroline Farrell before becoming a “Doll.” The show also follows some of the employees of the mysterious "Dollhouse" including Adele Dewitt, played Olivia Williams, who runs the Los Angeles branch of the organization; Boyd Langton, played by Henri J. Lennix, originally Echo's handler and then later the head of security; and Topher Brink, played by Fran Kranz, a young scientist who administers the imprinting technology, as well as two other "Dolls," Sierra and Victor (played by Dichen Lachman and Enver Gjokaj), who are friendly with Echo. The Dollhouse is under constant threat from Paul Ballard (Tahmoh Penikett), a determined federal agent who has been assigned to investigate rumors of the people being abducted and mind wiped by the “Dollhouse,” a case which the Bureau puts no stock in, despite the Dollhouse being aware of his investigation. The Dollhouse even goes so far as to embed a sleeper operative, November (played by Miracle Laurie), as his neighbor and budding love interest.

One of the first plot twist of the series is that no such abduction actually occurs, all of the Dolls are volunteers. Yes, although the operation is highly illegal we are led to believe that all operatives are ostensibly volunteers who work for a period of five years and are handsomely compensated at the expiration of their contract; the motivations explaining why operatives would agree to such a contract remains, if not entirely then largely ambiguous. Reasons suggested by the show range from economic need, political manipulation, and here is where the existential underpinnings of creator Joss Whedon begin to protrude, a desire to no longer be oneself. Indeed some of the major plot points unfolding during the first half of the season revolved around questions such as "Who is Caroline?" "Why did she volunteer to become Echo?" and "Is Caroline Echo?"

So who is Caroline? No one really that interesting, as it turns out. Caroline, a former student of Freemont College, was a radical animal’s rights activist who broke into a Rossum Corporation facility, along with boyfriend Leo, to expose the mistreatment of animals. They unwittingly discovers evidence, in the form of highly unethical and illegal scientific experiments, of the existence of the Dollhouse. Leo is killed, and Caroline hospitalized, trying to escape after their presences are exposed. Caroline escapes the hospital but is eventually apprehended, after two years, by the Dollhouse. Adelle DeWitt gives Caroline the ultimatum of going to jail or becoming an operative for 5 years, however, ultimately we are led to believe the reason that Caroline agrees is because she can no longer bear the guilt of Leo’s death.

Is Caroline, Echo? Well, this is the more interesting question with ample evidence for either side. The moral mouth piece of the show is FBI Agent Paul Ballard , who believes that the process of becoming a Doll is tantamount to murder. This claim is contradicted by the fact that Echo seems to show similar personality traits to Caroline and occasionally has glimpses of her past life. However, Echo is unique from most other dolls, as she appears to be evolving, or malfunctioning, as she shows signs of self-awareness in her mind-wiped stage as well as memories of past missions during engagements. Unfortunately, such malfunctioning has previously been recorded in the form of "Alpha," the mysterious villain of the show who at some point prior to the show began to "compositing" personalities. He eventually goes insane, kills a large but undisclosed amount of dolls, handlers, and miscellaneous employees of the Dollhouse. For unknown reasons, however, he spares two people: Echo and Dr. Claire Saunders, the in-house physician at the Dollhouse played by Amy Acker, to whom he does however inflict horrific wounds to the face.

After re-watching the penultimate episode of the season, Briar rose, and reading the Politics of Utopia by Fredric Jameson I began to contemplate what relation existentialism occupies with an idea of socialist utopia. There is a particular passage from Jameson, whose appropriateness on the matter I will let speak for itself:

"The science-fictional figure for such change is the situation in which a prisoner, or some potential rescue victim, is warned that salvation will be possible only at the price of allowing the entire personality—the past and its memories, all the multiple influences and events that have combined to form this current personality in the present—to be wiped away without a trace: a consciousness will alone remain, after this operation, but by what effort of the reason or imagination can it still be called ‘the same’ consciousness? The fear with which this prospect immediately fills us is then to all intents and purposes the same as the fear of death..." (pg 18)


After thinking on Dollhouse and this passage I have determined there are three major points that I would like to sketch out, however the number of tangential avenues they may lead down I am unsure off. I will return to these points in a future post and relate them in detail to the events of "Briar Rose" and the season finale "Omega."
  1. One of the most common arguments against communism is that it goes against human nature. I think this is an argument that we should meet on its own terms, it is unproductive to try to refute it by advocating its antithesis. No, I believe the proper response would be to acknowledge the argument as ultimately correct. It is equally as repugnant, and unsound, to claim man's essential character as altruistic as it is to claim it as self-interested. We must assert that "Yes! Communism does go against human nature," and it is because of this that the idea of socialist utopia fills us with such dread. It ultimately requires us to give up the political-historical referent, what we understand as "human nature" or Man as it has been named in this episteme, for a different referent.
  2. False Consciousness - this is a concept which has almost completely fallen out of philosophical favor. Zizek, following Althusser, jettisons the notion that ideology is false conciousness because ideology is consciousness. I think we need to take this one step further, all consciousness is false consciousness. I don't mean this in the weak sense that all consciousness is partial because it is rooted in a specific and narrow, racial/class/gender interpellated subjectivity, the underlying assumption being therefore if we eliminated these subject positions from society our consciousness would be less "divided." No, I mean sentience itself is false, the experience of the existential moment, inner life as such, is nessecarily abandoned in a socialist utopia.
  3. Existenialism (of the Sartreian humanist flavor which Joss Whedon open ascribes to), far from being radical, is perfectly accomodating to liberal democratic capitalist system by postulating sentience as not merely malleable by the individual by created ex nihlo.


FOX provided the following trailer in promotion of the show (though little of its content made it onto any episodes):


Dollhouse is a science-fiction series, created by Joss Whedon of Buffy and Firefly fame, which revolves around the exploits of an operatives of a mysterious organization known as the Dollhouse, the eponymous umbrella name for an organization that actually runs a myriad of dollhouses all over the world. These operatives, or "Actives" or "Dolls" as they are interchangeably called by the organization, are unique in that their personalities and memory of their existence in the outside world have been wiped clean so that they they may be imprinted with any number of new personalities for different assignments (referred to as engagements).

The new persona is an amalgam of several real people, which necessarily incorporates both strengths and flaws from the template personalities. The Actives are then hired out for engagements that can range anywhere from crimes to fantasies, to the occasional good deed. On engagements, Actives are monitored internally (and remotely) by Handlers. In between engagements they are mind-wiped into a child-like state and live in a futuristic dormitory, a hidden facility named "The Dollhouse." The Dollhouse is located somewhere in Los Angeles and is a subsidiary of a mysterious research company known as the Rossum Corporation. Dollhouse isn't exactly what one would call a "good" show. Don't get me wrong, it has its moments and had an especially strong second half of the season. However, it often found itself struggling with what type of show it wished to be (episodic doll-of-the-week, sci-fi police procedural, philosophically-driven concept show about human nature) and what audience it wished to draw.


The protagonist of the show is the operative Echo (all operatives are named after characters from the NATO phonetic alphabet), a young woman whose actual name was Caroline Farrell before becoming a “Doll.” The show also follows some of the employees of the mysterious "Dollhouse" including Adele Dewitt, played Olivia Williams, who runs the Los Angeles branch of the organization; Boyd Langton, played by Henri J. Lennix, originally Echo's handler and then later the head of security; and Topher Brink, played by Fran Kranz, a young scientist who administers the imprinting technology, as well as two other "Dolls," Sierra and Victor (played by Dichen Lachman and Enver Gjokaj), who are friendly with Echo. The Dollhouse is under constant threat from Paul Ballard (Tahmoh Penikett), a determined federal agent who has been assigned to investigate rumors of the people being abducted and mind wiped by the “Dollhouse,” a case which the Bureau puts no stock in, despite the Dollhouse being aware of his investigation. The Dollhouse even goes so far as to embed a sleeper operative, November (played by Miracle Laurie), as his neighbor and budding love interest.

One of the first plot twist of the series is that no such abduction actually occurs, all of the Dolls are volunteers. Yes, although the operation is highly illegal we are led to believe that all operatives are ostensibly volunteers who work for a period of five years and are handsomely compensated at the expiration of their contract; the motivations explaining why operatives would agree to such a contract remains, if not entirely then largely ambiguous. Reasons suggested by the show range from economic need, political manipulation, and here is where the existential underpinnings of creator Joss Whedon begin to protrude, a desire to no longer be oneself. Indeed some of the major plot points unfolding during the first half of the season revolved around questions such as "Who is Caroline?" "Why did she volunteer to become Echo?" and "Is Caroline Echo?"

So who is Caroline? No one really that interesting, as it turns out. Caroline, a former student of Freemont College, was a radical animal’s rights activist who broke into a Rossum Corporation facility, along with boyfriend Leo, to expose the mistreatment of animals. They unwittingly discovers evidence, in the form of highly unethical and illegal scientific experiments, of the existence of the Dollhouse. Leo is killed, and Caroline hospitalized, trying to escape after their presences are exposed. Caroline escapes the hospital but is eventually apprehended, after two years, by the Dollhouse. Adelle DeWitt gives Caroline the ultimatum of going to jail or becoming an operative for 5 years, however, ultimately we are led to believe the reason that Caroline agrees is because she can no longer bear the guilt of Leo’s death.

Is Caroline, Echo? Well, this is the more interesting question with ample evidence for either side. The moral mouth piece of the show is FBI Agent Paul Ballard , who believes that the process of becoming a Doll is tantamount to murder. This claim is contradicted by the fact that Echo seems to show similar personality traits to Caroline and occasionally has glimpses of her past life. However, Echo is unique from most other dolls, as she appears to be evolving, or malfunctioning, as she shows signs of self-awareness in her mind-wiped stage as well as memories of past missions during engagements. Unfortunately, such malfunctioning has previously been recorded in the form of "Alpha," the mysterious villain of the show who at some point prior to the show began to "compositing" personalities. He eventually goes insane, kills a large but undisclosed amount of dolls, handlers, and miscellaneous employees of the Dollhouse. For unknown reasons, however, he spares two people: Echo and Dr. Claire Saunders, the in-house physician at the Dollhouse played by Amy Acker, to whom he does however inflict horrific wounds to the face.

After re-watching the penultimate episode of the season, Briar rose, and reading the Politics of Utopia by Fredric Jameson I began to contemplate what relation existentialism occupies with an idea of socialist utopia. There is a particular passage from Jameson, whose appropriateness on the matter I will let speak for itself:

"The science-fictional figure for such change is the situation in which a prisoner, or some potential rescue victim, is warned that salvation will be possible only at the price of allowing the entire personality—the past and its memories, all the multiple influences and events that have combined to form this current personality in the present—to be wiped away without a trace: a consciousness will alone remain, after this operation, but by what effort of the reason or imagination can it still be called ‘the same’ consciousness? The fear with which this prospect immediately fills us is then to all intents and purposes the same as the fear of death..." (pg 18)


After thinking on Dollhouse and this passage I have determined there are three major points that I would like to sketch out, however the number of tangential avenues they may lead down I am unsure off. I will return to these points in a future post and relate them in detail to the events of "Briar Rose" and the season finale "Omega."
  1. One of the most common arguments against communism is that it goes against human nature. I think this is an argument that we should meet on its own terms, it is unproductive to try to refute it by advocating its antithesis. No, I believe the proper response would be to acknowledge the argument as ultimately correct. It is equally as repugnant, and unsound, to claim man's essential character as altruistic as it is to claim it as self-interested. We must assert that "Yes! Communism does go against human nature," and it is because of this that the idea of socialist utopia fills us with such dread. It ultimately requires us to give up the political-historical referent, what we understand as "human nature" or Man as it has been named in this episteme, for a different referent.
  2. False Consciousness - this is a concept which has almost completely fallen out of philosophical favor. Zizek, following Althusser, jettisons the notion that ideology is false conciousness because ideology is consciousness. I think we need to take this one step further, all consciousness is false consciousness. I don't mean this in the weak sense that all consciousness is partial because it is rooted in a specific and narrow, racial/class/gender interpellated subjectivity, the underlying assumption being therefore if we eliminated these subject positions from society our consciousness would be less "divided." No, I mean sentience itself is false, the experience of the existential moment, inner life as such, is nessecarily abandoned in a socialist utopia.
  3. Existenialism (of the Sartreian humanist flavor which Joss Whedon open ascribes to), far from being radical, is perfectly accomodating to liberal democratic capitalist system by postulating sentience as not merely malleable by the individual by created ex nihlo.


FOX provided the following trailer in promotion of the show (though little of its content made it onto any episodes):


Dollhouse is a science-fiction series, created by Joss Whedon of Buffy and Firefly fame, which revolves around the exploits of an operatives of a mysterious organization known as the Dollhouse, the eponymous umbrella name for an organization that actually runs a myriad of dollhouses all over the world. These operatives, or "Actives" or "Dolls" as they are interchangeably called by the organization, are unique in that their personalities and memory of their existence in the outside world have been wiped clean so that they they may be imprinted with any number of new personalities for different assignments (referred to as engagements).

The new persona is an amalgam of several real people, which necessarily incorporates both strengths and flaws from the template personalities. The Actives are then hired out for engagements that can range anywhere from crimes to fantasies, to the occasional good deed. On engagements, Actives are monitored internally (and remotely) by Handlers. In between engagements they are mind-wiped into a child-like state and live in a futuristic dormitory, a hidden facility named "The Dollhouse." The Dollhouse is located somewhere in Los Angeles and is a subsidiary of a mysterious research company known as the Rossum Corporation. Dollhouse isn't exactly what one would call a "good" show. Don't get me wrong, it has its moments and had an especially strong second half of the season. However, it often found itself struggling with what type of show it wished to be (episodic doll-of-the-week, sci-fi police procedural, philosophically-driven concept show about human nature) and what audience it wished to draw.


The protagonist of the show is the operative Echo (all operatives are named after characters from the NATO phonetic alphabet), a young woman whose actual name was Caroline Farrell before becoming a “Doll.” The show also follows some of the employees of the mysterious "Dollhouse" including Adele Dewitt, played Olivia Williams, who runs the Los Angeles branch of the organization; Boyd Langton, played by Henri J. Lennix, originally Echo's handler and then later the head of security; and Topher Brink, played by Fran Kranz, a young scientist who administers the imprinting technology, as well as two other "Dolls," Sierra and Victor (played by Dichen Lachman and Enver Gjokaj), who are friendly with Echo. The Dollhouse is under constant threat from Paul Ballard (Tahmoh Penikett), a determined federal agent who has been assigned to investigate rumors of the people being abducted and mind wiped by the “Dollhouse,” a case which the Bureau puts no stock in, despite the Dollhouse being aware of his investigation. The Dollhouse even goes so far as to embed a sleeper operative, November (played by Miracle Laurie), as his neighbor and budding love interest.

One of the first plot twist of the series is that no such abduction actually occurs, all of the Dolls are volunteers. Yes, although the operation is highly illegal we are led to believe that all operatives are ostensibly volunteers who work for a period of five years and are handsomely compensated at the expiration of their contract; the motivations explaining why operatives would agree to such a contract remains, if not entirely then largely ambiguous. Reasons suggested by the show range from economic need, political manipulation, and here is where the existential underpinnings of creator Joss Whedon begin to protrude, a desire to no longer be oneself. Indeed some of the major plot points unfolding during the first half of the season revolved around questions such as "Who is Caroline?" "Why did she volunteer to become Echo?" and "Is Caroline Echo?"

So who is Caroline? No one really that interesting, as it turns out. Caroline, a former student of Freemont College, was a radical animal’s rights activist who broke into a Rossum Corporation facility, along with boyfriend Leo, to expose the mistreatment of animals. They unwittingly discovers evidence, in the form of highly unethical and illegal scientific experiments, of the existence of the Dollhouse. Leo is killed, and Caroline hospitalized, trying to escape after their presences are exposed. Caroline escapes the hospital but is eventually apprehended, after two years, by the Dollhouse. Adelle DeWitt gives Caroline the ultimatum of going to jail or becoming an operative for 5 years, however, ultimately we are led to believe the reason that Caroline agrees is because she can no longer bear the guilt of Leo’s death.

Is Caroline, Echo? Well, this is the more interesting question with ample evidence for either side. The moral mouth piece of the show is FBI Agent Paul Ballard , who believes that the process of becoming a Doll is tantamount to murder. This claim is contradicted by the fact that Echo seems to show similar personality traits to Caroline and occasionally has glimpses of her past life. However, Echo is unique from most other dolls, as she appears to be evolving, or malfunctioning, as she shows signs of self-awareness in her mind-wiped stage as well as memories of past missions during engagements. Unfortunately, such malfunctioning has previously been recorded in the form of "Alpha," the mysterious villain of the show who at some point prior to the show began to "compositing" personalities. He eventually goes insane, kills a large but undisclosed amount of dolls, handlers, and miscellaneous employees of the Dollhouse. For unknown reasons, however, he spares two people: Echo and Dr. Claire Saunders, the in-house physician at the Dollhouse played by Amy Acker, to whom he does however inflict horrific wounds to the face.

After re-watching the penultimate episode of the season, Briar rose, and reading the Politics of Utopia by Fredric Jameson I began to contemplate what relation existentialism occupies with an idea of socialist utopia. There is a particular passage from Jameson, whose appropriateness on the matter I will let speak for itself:

"The science-fictional figure for such change is the situation in which a prisoner, or some potential rescue victim, is warned that salvation will be possible only at the price of allowing the entire personality—the past and its memories, all the multiple influences and events that have combined to form this current personality in the present—to be wiped away without a trace: a consciousness will alone remain, after this operation, but by what effort of the reason or imagination can it still be called ‘the same’ consciousness? The fear with which this prospect immediately fills us is then to all intents and purposes the same as the fear of death..." (pg 18)


After thinking on Dollhouse and this passage I have determined there are three major points that I would like to sketch out, however the number of tangential avenues they may lead down I am unsure off. I will return to these points in a future post and relate them in detail to the events of "Briar Rose" and the season finale "Omega."
  1. One of the most common arguments against communism is that it goes against human nature. I think this is an argument that we should meet on its own terms, it is unproductive to try to refute it by advocating its antithesis. No, I believe the proper response would be to acknowledge the argument as ultimately correct. It is equally as repugnant, and unsound, to claim man's essential character as altruistic as it is to claim it as self-interested. We must assert that "Yes! Communism does go against human nature," and it is because of this that the idea of socialist utopia fills us with such dread. It ultimately requires us to give up the political-historical referent, what we understand as "human nature" or Man as it has been named in this episteme, for a different referent.
  2. False Consciousness - this is a concept which has almost completely fallen out of philosophical favor. Zizek, following Althusser, jettisons the notion that ideology is false conciousness because ideology is consciousness. I think we need to take this one step further, all consciousness is false consciousness. I don't mean this in the weak sense that all consciousness is partial because it is rooted in a specific and narrow, racial/class/gender interpellated subjectivity, the underlying assumption being therefore if we eliminated these subject positions from society our consciousness would be less "divided." No, I mean sentience itself is false, the experience of the existential moment, inner life as such, is nessecarily abandoned in a socialist utopia.
  3. Existenialism (of the Sartreian humanist flavor which Joss Whedon open ascribes to), far from being radical, is perfectly accomodating to liberal democratic capitalist system by postulating sentience as not merely malleable by the individual by created ex nihlo.


FOX provided the following trailer in promotion of the show (though little of its content made it onto any episodes):